BRRR! What happened to that nice Georgia weather?
January is a time when the horse racing world is starting to wake up from the BCS (that's Breeder's Cup Slump, football fans) syndrome, and focus switches to the Triple Crown. But before we race fans can truly submerse ourselves in all things Kentucky Derby, we have one more piece of business from 2009 to take care of.
The Eclipse Awards.
The Eclipse Awards are the Oscars of the racing world, with Angelina Jolie and Julia Roberts being played by Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta, and Brad Pitt and George Clooney as Gio Ponti and Summer Bird. Named for one of the forefathers of the sport, Eclipse*, this award determines the best horses in these categories:
Two-Year-Old Male;
Two Year Old Filly;
Three Year Old Male;
Three Year Old Filly;
Older Male;
Older Female;
Male Sprinter;
Female Sprinter;
Male Turf Horse;
Female Turf Horse;
Steeplechase Horse;
Owner;
Breeder;
Trainer;
Jockey;
Apprentice Jockey; and
HORSE OF THE YEAR.
This year, there is great debate for Horse of the Year. And its between two lovely ladies: the powerful mare Zenyatta and the extraordinary filly Rachel Alexandra. It's exciting that the year's top honors are going to go between two leading ladies....a female has only won HOY three times before. Normally, a third horse is nominated, but who are we kidding? Rach and Zen are the cream of the crop and no one can top them. Both are undefeated this year. Both rocked the Boys Club in fashionable style. Both beat the best of their sex time and again. Rachel is 10 for 12 (placing second twice as a two-year-old) lifetime and Zenyatta is undefeated: 14 for 14 lifetime.
But as with any super hero, there are chinks in their armor. Zenyatta left the synthetic tracks of California only once. Rachel skipped the Breeder's Cup, which often is the deciding factor in year-end honors. And the biggest one: neither lady has faced each other. And with Zenyatta retired, and Rachel beginning her campaign in spring, the great debate is this: which outstanding lady deserves it more?
So I throw my hat in the ring. Not that I have a vote, but hey. Nice to dream, eh?
I have a soft spot in my heart for both, and will not be disappointed either way, but I believe Rachel deserves the crown. She was 8 for 8 this year, winning a Triple Crown race (the Preakness), the Haskell (against boys) and the Woodward (against older males) while beating up on her sex. Her awe-inspiring Kentucky Oaks win was one for the books; no other female has won the Oaks going away by 20 lengths. Her body of work is unbeatable....no other female has accomplished as much in one season. And, she's not done; there will be an outstanding four-year-old season to come.
If Zenyatta wins, it will be based on her whole body of work, not just this year. Yes, she is undefeated. And yes, she beat the Kentucky Derby, Travers, Belmont and Jockey Club Gold Cup winners (plus the best Euro horses that could make the trip) in the Classic. She is the first female to win the Classic in its 25-plus year history, and the first horse to win two different Breeder's Club races. But she never left California. She only raced five times. And she beat the same crowd of ladies that she beat the year before. While Rachel beat the boys three times, Zenyatta only beat them once. And one race, no matter how amazing it was, should not determine who is the year's best.
Zenyatta truly deserved the honor last year (given to Curlin, despite his diminishing form throughout the year), and it is unfortunate that she is up against Rachel this year.
But given the facts of this year, Rachel deserves it more. But we will see January 18th....and I am looking forward to seeing if my prediction is right.
Below (in case you are interested) are the horses nominated for each award, and in parentheses, who I would pick to win.
Horse of the Year: Rachel Alexandra, Zenyatta (RACHEL ALEXANDRA)
Two-Year-Old Male: Lookin at Lucky, Noble's Promise, Vale of York (LOOKIN AT LUCKY)
Two-Year-Old Filly: Blind Luck, Hot Dixie Chick, She Be Wild (SHE BE WILD)
Three-Year-Old Male: Mine That Bird, Quality Road, Summer Bird (SUMMER BIRD)
Three-Year-Old Filly: Careless Jewel, Flashing, Rachel Alexandra (RACHEL ALEXANDRA)
Older Male: Einstein, Gio Ponti, Kodiak Kowboy (GIO PONTI)
Older Female: Life Is Sweet, Music Note, Zenyatta (ZENYATTA)
Male Sprinter: Dancing in Silks, Kodiak Kowboy, Zensational (ZENSATIONAL)
Female Sprinter: Informed Decision, Music Note, Ventura (INFORMED DECISION)
Male Turf Horse: Conduit, Gio Ponti, Presious Passion (GIO PONTI)
Female Turf Horse: Goldikova, Midday, Ventura (VENTURA)
Steeplechase Horse: Mixed Up, Red Letter Day, Spy in the Sky (MIXED UP)
Owner: Godolphin, Juddmonte Farms, Mr. and Mrs. Jerome Moss (MR. AND MRS. JEROME MOSS)
Breeder: Adena Springs, Juddmonte Farms, Dolphus C. Morrison (DOLPHUS C. MORRISON)
Trainer: Steve Asmussen, Bob Baffert, John Shirreffs (JOHN SHIRREFFS)
Jockey: Ramon Dominguez, Garrett Gomez, Julien Leparoux (GARRETT GOMEZ)
Apprentice Jockey: Luis Batista, Christian Santiago Reyes, Luis Saez (CHRISTIAN SANTIAGO REYES)
*According to The BloodHorse, the Eclipse Awards are named after the great 18th-century racehorse and foundation sire Eclipse, who began racing at age 5 and was undefeated in 18 starts, including eight walkovers. Eclipse sired the winners of 344 races, including three Epsom Derbies (England).